Questions
Questions are the key to education. There is no other aspect that we can control more, or use to have a greater influence. Most of the time we think of questions as an assessment of learning, but we can't overlook how important they are to guiding learning. Questions will naturally happen in the classroom, but if we question ourselves on how we ask questions (see what I did there?) we can start asking at higher levels and some pretty cool stuff can happen.
Here are a few ideas (according to James E. Dyer) that I want to document because I feel are important to keep in mind:
- There are low and high levels of questions, and both are important in their own right. Low level questions Evaluate comprehension/preparation, diagnose strengths and weaknesses, and Review content. Higher levels of questions encourage deep/critical thinking and discussion, solve problems, and stimulate self-directed learning.
- Questions can be open or closed
- Wait time is a thing. It refers to how long you wait to solicit a response after asking. A good wait time is 3 seconds, but shouldn't be longer than 5-7 seconds.
- How you handle response to questions is just as much of a craft as what you ask.
I know that asking the right questions is a matter of practice. After a while, we will be asking appropriate questions with little conscious effort. Nevertheless I still want to consciously improve this skill, specifically responding to answers correctly. (If you watch my labs, you will see I could use work on this). I will continue to dive into this and work on it with my peers and Mr. Brown.
Students Matter
While the first part of our weekly investment was important to developing my pedagogy, I feel the second part was equally important to developing my passion. More than any other piece of information my students will learn in class, I want them to know they matter. One of the main reasons I went into ag education over anything else is that ag teachers have such a unique opportunity to work with students as people as well as learners. I have had many good talks in this matter. One example is taken from a recent email with Mr. Brown. He said: "I had a class of 9th grade students today make a statement that said, Mr. Brown we wish all teachers were like you and Mr. Turner-teachers that get to know us as people not just students and that really care about what we do on a daily basis."This comes back to Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. As the Ted Talks pointed out, if students feel like their ideas matter, they will create wonderful things! Also, this feeling of importance is more than a facade that we construct as a tool to achieve an end result. It has to be real! I know this because I experienced this as a high school student.
My senior year, I had Mrs. Hyde for English. The classroom engagement was pretty average as far as English classes go, but I will always remember the custom poster she had at the front of her room. By this point, I knew I wanted to teach ag, so before I knew any of the theories behind it that I know now, I wrote it down and promised myself that I would have a similar one in my classroom one day. I will leave you with a similar copy below. Remember: we are more than simple teachers. We have the ability to make a positive difference in the lives of students by developing premier leadership, personal growth and career success each and every day while we instruct our curriculum to the future of the agricultural industry!
Nate, I couldn't agree more. Mr. Clark says a quote that goes something like "students don't know how much you care until you show you care". As we near our student teaching experience, I am starting to realize that there are so many things we have to juggle (lessons, objectives, standards, tests, administration, contracts, classroom management, and the list goes on). With just enough time to shove down our lunches and make some copies, we have to also make sure we are spending time caring for our students. Yet this above everything is the most important! I'm starting to realize how much additional work teachers do that aren't included in any advertisement or job description.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteNate, I couldn't agree with you more. Questions are the key to education! I also liked how you added Maslow's Hierarchy of needs in with your questions. It really ties our lessons that we have had so far together.
ReplyDeleteNate, I really like that you how touched on how important questions are to guiding learning, not only assessing learning.
ReplyDeleteAnd man, the fact that we have the ability to show students they matter. Woah. That's a lot, but what a cool position to be in.
Can you explain more about this: Also, this feeling of importance is more than a facade that we construct as a tool to achieve an end result. It has to be real!" I like it but I don't quite know what you mean?
Basically, you can not fake caring about students. You can not just say "I care about you" hoping it will boost moral. Students can tell when a feeling is genuine, and they will react best when that is the case. That being said, I don't think anyone in our cohort will have an issue with this sincerity!
DeleteNate, I really like that you how touched on how important questions are to guiding learning, not only assessing learning.
ReplyDeleteAnd man, the fact that we have the ability to show students they matter. Woah. That's a lot, but what a cool position to be in.
Can you explain more about this: Also, this feeling of importance is more than a facade that we construct as a tool to achieve an end result. It has to be real!" I like it but I don't quite know what you mean?
"They don't care how much you know until they know how much you care." Get it right Miranda. I love the sign. I still don't feel super comfortable with the everyone is a winner mindset. I just think we need to be careful about how we address those issues. I do think students need to know that they matter and that they can achieve great things. I relate it a little to the idea of the Foster saying which or purse now that I made fun of Miranda I can't remember exactly. It's something about challenging being good but impossible is bad. I know a kid who was told he was smart and could do anything his whole life. He has just about every advantage life in American can offer yet he dropped out of college and sits at home playing video games all the time. I don't know the deep issues that are going on with him. I just know that maybe if someone had told him he was going to have to work for it, and that failure happens he might be doing a lot better now.
ReplyDeleteIt is sometimes easy to get caught up in all of the elements of effective teaching and standards that we have to meet and forget about the really important things. This blog has helped me remember that showing students that you truly care, even the punk student in your class, and that you want them to be successful. That being said, sometimes students dont see things the same way we do and that is ok. We are not there to be their buddies, but we can develop rapport with students that makes them feel that they can come to you if they have problems or are struggling with something
ReplyDeleteNice bringing up "We are not there to be their buddies, but we can develop rapport with students." I feel like that idea is known but not said aloud as much.
DeleteThanks!
ReplyDelete